Theme: Captivity of animals
Claim – Is it ethical to hold animals captive, or is simply a form of entertainment?
Essay: Blackfish –
Watch the Blackfish documentary. You will then gather other evidence for an argumentative essay regarding the captivity of sea mammals (or animals).
Blackfish ~
Blackfish is a documentary that reveals the grim side of marine parks such as Sea World. Whether the claims presented in the documentary are completely accurate, or not, one can definitely debate if these sea mammals should be held captive or live freely, in the wild.
Time to debate: Carefully consider both sides of the issue, choose a side and support your position in an argumentative essay. Debate the ethics of capturing sea mammals for the purpose of entertainment or leaving them to live freely in their natural habitat. Both sides of the issue have merit, but you must choose one. One possible claim could be: The public should not support marine park programs because these programs use inhumane practices to separate killer whales from their natural habitat and social groups, which is extremely detrimental to the well-being of the mammal. You may even choose to find evidence that supports captivity of killer whales. Example: Marine parks should be supported; not only do these programs provide memorable family entertainment, they provide environmental education, and teach appreciation for sea mammals.
Another option is to develop your own claim related to the captivity of animals.
This essay should:
Clearly identify your position in your claim/thesis.
Discuss a counterargument and a refutation
Provide ample support from additional sources; the documentary is not enough (include 4 or more sources).
Be typed, MLA format – double space, 12 point font, Times New Roman
Be a minimum of 4 pages
Include a Works cited page
