Can we give a completely general answer to the Special Composition Question? Or, will the answer depend on the type of whole under consideration? Answer by engaging the views of Peter van Inwagen and Peter Simons.

Can we give a completely general answer to the Special Composition Question? Or, will the

answer depend on the type of whole under consideration? Answer by engaging the views of

Peter van Inwagen and Peter Simons (aka, the part-whole Peters).